|
COMMENT:
LEADERSHIP ON THE MOVE
'Let me pass.
I have to follow them. I am their leader.'
Alexandre
Auguste Ledru-Rollin (1807-1874)
French lawyer and politician
'Youve
observed how godless rulers throw their weight around,' Jesus said,
'and when people get a little power how quickly it goes to their
heads. Its not going to be that way with you. Whoever wants
to be great must become a servant. Whoever wants to be first among
you must be your slave. That is what the Son of Man has done. He
came to serve you, not to be served and then to give away
his life in exchange for many who are held hostage.'
Mark 10:41-45
The Message
In thinking
about Christian leadership there are several pitfalls to be avoided.
One of the most obvious is being seduced by concepts of leadership
that are flavour of the month in, for example, political and business
spheres. Likewise the reverse of this: the outright rejection of
such models and techniques because in their theory they are thought
to be at odds with the gospel and in practice are often carried
to excess.
Both of these
responses betray an unthinking approach characterised, respectively,
by the aphorisms 'swallowing it hook, line and sinker' and 'throwing
the baby out with the bath water'.
It is also
important to be aware that the leadership model(s) which we have
experienced, perhaps in our fellowships and denominations or through
observing Christians in the world of politics or business, are not
the only ones available. We should be more ready to evaluate them
and in so doing obey the biblical injunction to 'first remove the
beam that is in your own eye.'
Inherent in
the concept of leadership is movement. This is clearly demonstrated
in the lives of numerous biblical characters. This means, amongst
other things, reading the signs of the times in a changing world;
asking the hard questions about values and priorities and acknowledging
failure. It is setting an example that will not only inspire and
enthuse the people of God but will speak to the world outside through
the radical nature of the message and the gracious manner in which
it is communicated.
One of the
roles of a leader is to challenge those who take refuge in the status
quo. Comments such as, 'we have always done it this way' or 'we
have never done it that way' or 'if it isnt broke dont
fix it' frequently come from people in positions of leadership in
a congregation. This exemplifies the difference between being a
leader and occupying a leadership position. It also raises the question,
'by what processes are leadership positions filled?'
It would be
interesting to know what motivates those who express such sentiments.
In so doing are they displaying a sub-conscious desire to exercise
control rather than discharge their leadership function?
Of the quotations
at the beginning, the first displays a stark honesty and is seen
in action day and daily: when a politician derives his/her mandate
from victory in an election it is understandable that he or she
will be particularly sensitive to the wishes of the electorate and
will have an eye to the next poll.
In the second
quotation, Jesus is acutely aware of human nature and our propensity
to let power go to our heads. The only antidote is to recognise
this and model ourselves on him. Two differences are noteworthy
in comparison. One is the motive of the budding leader regarding
the led. In the former case it was to dignify the self-interest
of the crowd, in the latter the temporal and spiritual welfare of
his people. A further difference is the expectation that each had
for their future. The former seemingly looked for popularity, while
Jesus wise to the temptation 'set his face to go to
Jerusalem', to end up on a cross.
Leadership,
then, is not a right to be exercised but a trust to be discharged.
STANLEY McDOWELL
is a member of Fitzroy Presbyterian Church and spent his career
in the public sector in central and local government.
|